Print Version

 Solvers Puzzles Basic Strategies Tough Strategies Diabolical Strategies Extreme Strategies Depreciated Strategies Str8ts Other
 Order Now! Order Now!
Double Line/Box Reduction

This article is part two of the new Double Intersection Removal strategy specifically for Jigsaw Sudoku puzzles. I recommend reading part one on Double Pointing Pairs first. I am indebted to Brain Hobson's observations for this excellent prod in the right direction and I am appreciating Jigsaws in a whole new way.

With Line/Box Reduction we take one box and one line (a row or column) and look for a specific number that only exists in the overlap of that box and line. So by looking along a row you may see that all the 2s are in the same box (or shape). If that is the case we know the solution will be one of those cells - otherwise the row would lose that number altogether. From this idea we can remove the rest of those candidates from the box or shape in question.

With Jigsaw Puzzles we have shapes that overlap rows and columns in a much more chaotic and interesting way. Unlike normal Sudoku, we can ask, what if we have two rows (or columns) where candidates X are present in just two shapes. In that case, we can be certain that there will be two solutions (one for both boxes and both rows/columns) so any other candidate X in those shapes can simply go. (The doubling up theme is not new. Consider how X-Wings are a doubled up version of Hidden Pairs).

 Here is a very illustrative puzzle with lots of examples - both of the normal Intersection Removal and the doubled up version. Down the center are two columns where 2 is present in shapes 4 and 5 - and just those two shapes. Shapes 4 and 5 have many other possible 2s - but they can all be removed. The solver returns the result:Double Line/Box ReductionThe two columns 4 and 5 contain 2 in just boxes 1 and 2, so...- 2 can be removed from A1- 2 can be removed from A2- 2 can be removed from B2- 2 can be removed from H6- 2 can be removed from J8 Double Line/Box Reduction on 2: Load Example or : From the Start
 In almost the next step we can remove a bunch of 3s as well, this time but looking at the first two rows and how they overlap with boxes 1 and 8.Double Line/Box ReductionThe two rows 1 and 2 contain 3 in just boxes 1 and 8, so...- 3 can be removed from D4- 3 can be removed from D5- 3 can be removed from E5 Double Line/Box Reduction on 3: Load Example or : From the Start
 In exactly the same way doubled up Pointing Pairs work - the two rows and columns do not need to be adjacent - they must only overlap the same two shapes at some point. Here is an example with 4s being removed on a "tough" grade puzzle where the rows are not adjacent.Double Line/Box ReductionThe two rows 4 and 6 contain 4 in just boxes 5 and 6, so...- 4 can be removed from G4- 4 can be removed from H4 Double Line/Box Reduction on 4: Load Example or : From the Start

 Go back to Double Pointing Pairs Continue to Law of Leftovers

Email Address - required for confirmation (it will not be displayed here)

 Please enter theletters you see: Remember me
confirm your comment. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags.

## Friday 26-Jul-2013

### ... by: ralph maier

in todays puzzle thereis a trivial exampple of 4 line box reduction of4s in column 6 7 89 so the 4s in ABC5 can be eliminated

## Wednesday 10-Jul-2013

### ... by: ralph maier

Dear Mr Stuart
I do Jigsaw seldom mostly Str8ts and Sudoku. Anyhow I saw for the first time DOUBLE box REDUCTION. This can be genmeralized to N lines or boxes.

Andrew Stuart writes:

Correct, this can be extended to triples or further. Depends on the shapes. I mention it on the next page but I've not extended the solver that far.